• Menu
Home » North America » USA » Common New York Scams & How To Avoid Them

Common New York Scams & How To Avoid Them

This article may contain affiliate links, which may earn us a commission - at no extra cost to you - if you use one of our links. Please see our disclosures page for more information.

New York City – where Wall Street wannabes come to make money, fashionistas walk the posh shopping districts, and sadly, where some people just want to make a quick buck through scams.

It’s not just people in NYC that try to rip off unsuspecting tourists, this is true in most cities.

But there are some scams that are notorious in New York, and we witnessed nearly all of these during our short trip there earlier this year.

Read on to find out what you should watch out for in New York, and how to avoid the most common New York scams.

Brooklyn Bridge, New York City

1. Unofficial taxi cabs at JFK airport

When you’ve gone through passport control and baggage reclaim in JFK, you should spot the queue for a taxi cab fairly quickly.

The large yellow signs stating where to get an official yellow cab from are pretty recognisable.

If anyone approaches you on your way to that queue stating that they can offer you a cheaper ride, or that you’ve gone to the wrong line – do not listen to them!

They’re either trying to take you to a quiet area to mug you, charge you obscene amounts for your taxi fare, or they’re trying to avoid paying airport fees to pick up passengers.

Just stick with safety and grab the official yellow cabs.

2. CD bullies and Times Square CD hustlers

You may come across people wanting to give you a ‘free’ CD… actually, call it ‘free’ anything.

Nothing is free in New York.

If you take the CD, or whatever it is someone’s trying to offer you, they’ll quickly demand at least $5, if not more than that.

And if you don’t give them what they’re asking for, they can get nasty.

If you want to take a CD home as a souvenir, just head to a legitimate shop – it’s much safer!

Dash & Lily Filming Locations in NYC

3. Cheap subway tickets and cards

In many subway stations (even those off the beaten track), you’ll notice people trying to sell you a cheap subway ticket or card.

They’ll often cry that you’re going to pay extra at the machines.

But the chances are very high that the ticket they’re offering only has enough on it to get you through the barrier once, rather than a full day or several days ticket they’ve probably charged you for.

4. Unofficial tickets, tours and attractions

Particularly around popular tourist destinations like Times Square, you’ll likely have a number of people try to sell you some kind of tour, or ticket to a popular attraction.

Just don’t bother! Buy your ticket from the official box office, or in advance online.

The scamming touts may be pushy, they may insult you, heck, they may even try to intimidate you… just walk away.

Manhattan Bridge, New York City

5. The Staten Island Ferry

Although this comes under the heading of not buying from street touts, it’s such a common NYC scam that I thought it needed its own paragraph.

The official Staten Island Ferry is FREE!

Therefore, anyone trying to sell you a ticket outside the ferry terminal is a liar and a scammer.

RELATED: 4 Day New York Itinerary For First Time Visitors

6. Pedicab ripoffs and overcharges

If you’re going to make like a tourist and hop in a pedicab, or horse-drawn carriage ride (generally around Central Park), then beware of some people who’ll try to rip you off or overcharge you.

To avoid this scam, ensure you agree to your fare upfront with the driver.

By law, pedicab drivers are actually supposed to advertise their prices on the front of the cab, although some will try to get away with not doing this if possible.

If the price they’re quoting is too much, just walk away… they’ll likely call you back with a lower price anyway.

As a general rule of thumb, you can expect to pay between $3 to $7 per minute, per ride, while the main pedicab operator’s website has prices by the hour as shown here.

New York in the rain

7. TV and movie characters posing for a photo

This one is true of anyone wanting to pose for a photo in most cities, although this is highly prevalent in New York (particularly in and around Times Square).

A quick pose for a photo by Spiderman or Miss Piggy is not technically free!

If you’re determined to get a photo with your favourite TV or movie character, then agree on the price upfront before having the photo taken.

And keep an eye on your personal belongings while posing (just in case)!

8. Fake ‘monks’ in New York City

One last thing to watch out for in New York, and a very common scam around the city, is people posing as monks.

They’ll try to offer you some kind of ‘gift’ such as some incense or to ask you to sign their wishbook or something, only to then demand money afterwards.

Just politely avoid these people at all costs just to be on the safe side.

Common New York Scams & How To Avoid Them
If you're finding our blog posts helpful, we would love it if you would consider donating to our "Buy Me A Coffee" site. Thank you so much for your support xoxo
Justine Jenkins

Justine is one half of the married couple behind the Wanderers of the World travel blog. She lives in Bristol, UK and has travelled extensively within Europe and beyond since 2013. After her trips, she shares detailed travel itineraries, helpful travel guides and inspiring blog posts about the places she's been to. When she's not travelling overseas, you'll find her joining her husband, Scott on various day trips, weekend getaways and walks within the UK, which she also writes about on Wanderers of the World. Aside from travelling and writing, she also loves reading, crafting and learning about nature.

View stories

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *